First-time Subscribers: Are You Inadvertently Turning Them Away?

Today’s guest blog post is written by Shasti Walsh, Training Specialist, Patron Technology. 

Dear arts marketers: I am your prime target.

I’m a long-time arts fan and frequent single-ticket buyer to many different organizations. I’m also reaching a point in my life where I’m a bit more financially secure and my schedule is a little more predictable. Two years ago I bought my first choose-your-own package of six shows at my favorite local performing arts organization; this year I upgraded to a full season package and started looking at introductory packages at other organizations. When I receive a brochure, via mail or email, I read through it for shows that interest me, and if I find more than three or so, I start thinking “Hmm, maybe I’ll try a small subscription this year.”

But recently, on two separate occasions, I planned to buy first-time subscription packages but have yet to follow through. Why?

Dear arts marketers: I am also your classic shopping-cart-abandoner.

In the first instance, I received a mailing from an organization I visit regularly. The brochure was gorgeous. The images were exciting, the show descriptions were compelling, and a few different pages mentioned that I could build my own subscription starting with as few as three shows — I was hooked! I made it all the way through the brochure, circling the shows I was most excited about along the way, eager to buy my first mini-subscription to the organization and lock in my seats in advance. I got to the end of the brochure, credit card in hand, ready to place my order, but there was no order form. 

Then I went back to the beginning, looking to see if I had somehow missed the part where it listed any details about various package options, such as the price, or where it said “To order your subscription, _____”, I hadn’t.

I then went on their website and clicked around until I found the “subscribe” link. I chose the build-your-own option on the menu and tried to add the shows I had circled in the brochure, but it turned out only one of those shows was available with a build-your-own package — the rest were only available as part of a different targeted full series. At that point, I gave up and decided that I’d buy single tickets to the shows I wanted to see, later, once single tickets are on sale if I remembered.

About a week later, I got a marketing email from a local classical music organization, and opened it on my phone, as I normally do. It mentioned a limited-time offer on a create-your-own package and had intriguing teasers about what the full season contained. I got excited and clicked through to see what options I might want and if a subscription might work for me.

The instructions said to “click here to choose your shows” so I clicked… the link opened a single scrolling list of the entire season (well over 100 performances), listed by performance date, in a non-phone-friendly format. For each option, all I could see was something like “SATURDAY 9/9/2017, 8:00PM — BEETHO…” I made a valiant effort, swapping between two tabs to read the performance descriptions in one and match that up with dates in the second, but after a solid ten minutes of that, you guessed it, I gave up. I’ll probably buy single tickets, though, once they go on sale, that is if I remember.

Dear arts marketers: I am feeling a little discouraged.

You’ve got great materials, your brochures are stunning, and your emails are compelling. But have you streamlined the steps your first-time subscribers will have to take in-between getting excited and submitting their order? Is your website mobile-optimized? Pretend to buy a subscription on your phone and see how it looks! Does your brochure include obvious information about how to place an order? Read through it as if you’re a stranger and make sure those instructions are clear.

A few days after the second instance, I got another season email from a different theater. This one was also exciting and made me think I might like to subscribe. In this case, I clicked through (again, on my phone), the website was phone-friendly and easy to navigate, the subscription options were straightforward, and less than a minute later I was a proud new subscriber to a theater I’ve been attending as a single ticket buyer for years. Now I can’t wait to bring my friends!

Suggested Blog Posts

Learn More about PatronManager, the powerful CRM platform that helps you sell more tickets, raise more money, and cultivate stronger bonds with your audience, all in one database.